John dewey never made it into the club he was thirteen in 1872, but he dominates the last third of the book. Daniel kevles, yale university the metaphysical club is a brilliant reanimation of american pragmatism. The one that is followed here runs throgh the lives of four people. Crossing the divide between academic analysis and insightful storytelling, this social and intellectual history explores the ideas of pragmatism by charting the lives of its founding. The metaphysical club of the books title flourished for only a few months in cambridge in 1872. This book is an effort to write about these ideas in their own spiritthat is, to try to see ideas as always soaked through by the.
The metaphysical club is the formal center of the book, but the rise and spread of pragmatism is the central theme. Holmes, james, peirce, and dewey were philosophers, and their work is part of the history of abstract thought. For anyone expecting hard data about how to build an overunity device, it will be a disappointment, but it does cover a few interesting topics. The triumph of the metaphysical club is the authors dramatic demonstration of the parallel between developments in science and philosophy. These are just two early examples of a phenomenon i have come to take for granted. Unlike mills, he finds himself at books end with no criteria clear enough to mount a firm evaluation. For the past 25 years or so the western book market has been inundated with a plethora of commodified spiritual prescriptions. The metaphysical club is the winner of the 2002 pulitzer prize for history. The metaphysical club is not the final authority on any of these subjects. The metaphysical club louis menand pdf a story of ideas in. Metaphysical book club and discussion group facebook. The civil war made america a modern nation, unleashing forces of industrialism and expansion that had been kept in check for decades by the quarrel over slavery. The metaphysical club book deschutes public library.
This idea informs the writings of these three thinkers, and the work of the fourth figure in the book, john dewey student of peirce, friend and ally of james, admirer of holmes. It was an impressive collection that id assembled in a matter of weeks. The book s vehicle for describing the early decades of pragmatism is a discussion of a group of thinkers in cambridge, massachusetts, who participated in a loosely organized club that, in fact, called itself the. This club had two primary phases, distinguished from each other by the most active participants and the topics pursued. The metaphysical club expresses the distance traveled by modern public intellectuals away from these assumptions. Find books like the metaphysical club from the worlds largest community of readers. The metaphysical club is a very good, broad survey of an interesting and significant slice of american intellectual history, which also considers the larger implications of the ideas that are considered.
Below is a list of all the free pdf books authors on this site. The book is divided in to five parts plus a prologue and epilogue. The metaphysical club spent a whole lot of time on bestseller lists, and won a pulitzer prize for its author, louis menand. The four men are the legal scholar oliver wendell holmes, jr. Its subtitle, a story of ideas in america, gives some indication on what the book is about, but until you actually read the book you cannot begin to grasp its depth and sheer brilliance. While it ventures into many different directions, covering topics in american history, notable pioneers of american higher education and philosophy, it mainly concerns the erosion of metaphysics and its eventual replacement by pragmatism as a dominant force in shaping american. Oct 02, 2001 the metaphysical club, by louis menand. Abrams, the basis for the modern law of free speech. Weve continued through a variety of subjects and authors as we work our way on the path of life and living. Apr 10, 2002 the metaphysical club is the winner of the 2002 pulitzer prize for history a riveting, original book about the creation of modern american thought. A full account of the metaphysical club, featuring the members philosophical writings and four critical essays.
He discusses the ideas that came from the informal group that impacted societys way of thinking. Save over 20% credits will not expire, so you can use them at any time. Winner of the 2002 pulitzer prize for historya riveting, original book about the creation of modern. A riveting, original book about the creation of modern american thought. The metaphysical club meetings, johns hopkins university. The topics considered in this book represent only a selection from the issues that prove central when philosophers attempt to identify the categories of being. The books vehicle for describing the early decades of pragmatism is a discussion of a group of thinkers in cambridge, massachusetts, who participated in a loosely organized club that, in fact, called itself the. The book is about four philosophers, three of whom helped form the metaphysical club in 1872. A story of ideas in america and millions of other books are available for instant access. Read the metaphysical club by louis menand for free with a 30 day free trial. A riveting, original book about the creation of modern american tho. The metaphysical club was a similarly looseknit group that lasted for probably no more than nine months in 1872, but louis menand uses it as the fulcrum to balance his account of the major. So much for the most prominent contemporary pragmatist, richard rorty, who remains unmentioned except in the acknowledgments. The metaphysical club is louis menands awardwinning book about the emergence of pragmatism as a distinct school of thought.
The spiritual book market is absolutely saturated with choices. Some of them wonderful contributions, others not so much. Menand discusses the intellectual and social conditions that helped. But the war also discredited the ideas and beliefs of the era that preceded it. The metaphysical club discusses how the american thought processes in law, science, philosophy and religion were changed by four people. By so emphasizing personal qualities, menand asks less of his subjects as thinkers, and thus less of his readers as critics. We start with eric butterworths discover the power within a guide to the unexplored depths within. The metaphysical club is the biography of four men and an idea.
Book i 1 when the objects of an inquiry, in any department, have principles, conditions, or elements, it is through acquaintance with these that knowledge, that is to say scientific knowledge, is attained. Jun 04, 2001 none of the letters, diaries or other writings by members of the metaphysical club ever saw fit to mention the groups brief existence, in cambridge, mass. Delaware county district library ohio scanned in china. The metaphysical club is a compellingly vital account of how the cluster of ideas that came to be called pragmatism was forged from the searing experiences of its progenitors lives. Jul 17, 20 the spiritual book market is absolutely saturated with choices.
Metaphysical club journal of american history oxford. If you would like to learn more about a particular author listed in the metaphysical bookstore click on the authors name. A story of ideas in america is a pulitzer prizewinning 2001 book by louis menand, an american writer and legal scholar, which won the 2002 pulitzer prize for history. The doors of the metaphysical club look intimidating, but dont be put. Coetzee, in a strange room is the intricate, psychologically intense, and deeply personal book of fiction from the internationally acclaimed, man booker prizeshortlisted author of the good doctor. Its members included three young men who would later achieve intellectual prominence the philosopher and psychologist william james, the future supreme court justice oliver wendel holmes jr. The metaphysical club isbn 9780374528492 pdf epub louis. The metaphysical club is a 2002 pulitzerprizewinning book by louis menand about holmes, james, and peirce.
The metaphysical club is the winner of the 2002 pulitzer prize for history a riveting, original book about the creation of modern american thought. Unlike mills, he finds himself at book s end with no criteria clear enough to mount a firm evaluation. This overview of the free energy scene by jeane manning and her new coauthor, susan manewich, has high and low points. Enjoy over 175 free pdf books on the law of attraction and metaphysics. B ringing these books together was the idea that sparked the law of attraction haven. The music belongs to bob dylan and the recording studio he goes through. Menand brings pragmatists of the metaphysical club to life. The civil war swept away the slave civilization of the south, but almost the whole intellectual. Read the metaphysical club pdf a story of ideas in america by louis.
Over the years i have searched for each of these books individually and always thought it would be great to find them in one place. Goodreads members who liked the metaphysical club also liked. This book is an effort to write about these ideas in their own spiritthat is, to try to see ideas as always soaked through by the personal and social sitiations in whch we find them. The metaphysical club was an informal group that met in cambridge. Metaphysical club journal of american history oxford academic. This way of thinking lasted until the beginning of the cold war. The book recounts the lives and intellectual work of the handful of thinkers primarily responsible for the philosophical concept of pragmatism, a. The metaphysical club, a gathering of intellectuals in the 1870s, is widely recognized as the crucible where pragmatism, americas distinctively original philosophy, was refined and proclaimed. The metaphysical club was an informal group of boston philosophers and jurists who met over the course of nine months during the year of 1872.
The metaphysical club by louis menand book read online. So much for the most prominent contemporary pragmatist, richard rorty, who remains unmen. Pdf the johns hopkins metaphysical club and its impact on the. He catches the rhythms of 19thcentury america with striking clarity, swinging from complex explanations to epigraphic summaries. Wendy ann hrynewski for metaphysical book club and discussion group. Winner of the 2002 pulitzer prize for historya riveting, original book about the creation of modern american thought.
Pdf the metaphysical club download full pdf book download. Louis menand winner of the 2002 pulitzer prize for history a riveting, original book about the creation of modern american thought. May 01, 2001 the metaphysical club is louis menands awardwinning book about the emergence of pragmatism as a distinct school of thought. They didnt just want to keep the conversation going. Read unlimited books and audiobooks on the web, ipad, iphone and android. However, i do not think the peirce club was really about the importance of ideas, as menand asserts, and i doubt that its members were giants of american thought, unless one believes that the standard for being a giant is lower in.
Metaphysical club \htilky james recovering from wounds rcceived in the attack on fort \yagner, 1863 drawing by \killiarn jamrs. An evening to meet, greet and share with likeminded people. A thoroughly entertaining and often thoughtprovoking read, it can certainly be recommended. The book recounts the lives and intellectual work of the handful of thinkers primarily responsible for the philosophical concept of. After a few weeks i had a stack of books about a foot or so high about prophecies, plus videos and piles of printed web pages. The metaphysical club was an informal group that met in cambridge, massachusetts, in 1872, to talk about ideas. The metaphysical club was an informal discussion group of scholarly friends, close from their associations with harvard university, that started in 1871 and continued until spring 1879. The metaphysical club quotes showing of 59 if you look up a word in the dictionary, you find it defined by a string of other words, the meanings of which can be discovered by looking them up in a dictionary, leading to more words that can be looked up in turn.
1035 892 1379 1426 90 362 1027 137 16 930 1176 72 113 165 1567 319 1201 225 198 1137 1184 1213 850 99 721 313 1416 1444 1202 691 1479 930